This is a subject that upsets a lot of people, particularly Americans. It does not fit with the narrative that many Americans believe in, that the United States has played the most heroic role ever since it came into existence, and that the world would be inextricably worse than it is without us. Indeed, many Americans believe that Europe would probably be speaking German today, if not for them.
Only one problem with that theory and thinking: it is really not accurate.
Indeed, I mentioned this a few times, here and there, to some people who got angry, and even once or twice, almost violently angry, accusing me of being virtually a communist sympathizer. All I generally do in response is simply request that whoever is getting all worked up look at the dates of what happened and when during World War II or, better yet, peruse through a historical atlas of the Second World War. Because any halfway decent review of historical facts will show that, in fact, the Soviet Union was the driving force behind the ultimate defeat of Nazi Germany.
Most people, including military experts like Norman Schwartzkopf, have been quite clear that the biggest mistake that Hitler and Nazi Germany ever made was invading the Soviet Union, which they did in June of 1941. Of course, up to that point, the Nazi war machine had rolled across Europe, winning one battle after another. It seemed that they were in a dominant position to that point, and when they first started quickly going through vast territories that had been part of the Soviet Union, it looked like it was happening again.
But that ended abruptly once the Germans were locked in far inside of Soviet territory, and particularly once that infamous Russian winter began to take hold.
There were many reasons for what happened next, and how it all contributed to the eventual German defeat. The Soviet Union did not have the infrastructure that western Europe had, and so many of the roads became virtually impassable when there was rain and the roads became muddy, or in the brutal Russian winters. That meant that supplies, including food, was very slow to get there, when the Germans needed them.
Yet, it was more than that. When Stalin realized that Hitler and the Nazis had betrayed the non-aggression pact between the two countries, he became completely committed to defeating the Germans. That does not make him a hero, or any less brutal in history. In fact, it was his brutality that perhaps was one of the deciding factors forcing the outcome in favor of the Soviets. How so? Well, he made sure that the Soviet troops fighting the Germans had guns pointed at their backs, to make sure that any deserters would be shot on the spot. They could not surrender to the Germans, nor turn their heels and retreat. They really had not choice but to fight the Germans tooth and nail, and indeed, 20 million Soviets lost their lives. Yet, in the end, this was what broke the back of the war hopes of Hitler and Nazi Germany.
Of course, mentioning just how critical the role of the Soviets was in defeating Nazi Germany is often viewed as blasphemous by those who subscribe to American exceptionalism, and who view history through that lens. First of all, it seriously challenges the American centrist theme during World War II, particularly in Europe, which again, many Americans subscribe to. But going even further, a lot of people simply do not want to give any credit to the big, bad, Commie Soviets for doing anything positive.
However, John Adams was right. Facts are stubborn things. And the facts bear the truth out: the Germans concentrated their main forces in the war on their eastern front, against the Soviets. When it became clear that they were losing, they tried to get the western powers to join them in the fight, to see the Soviet Union as the real threat, although they had no real success in this. It was the Soviet forces who stopped the Nazi war machine in it's track, particularly with the Battle of Stalingrad, which still ranks as the deadliest battle in all of history. From that point onward, the Soviets pushed the Germans back, closer and closer to the border of the Reich and, eventually, forced Nazi Germany to collapse in on itself, with the eventual help of the western allies, who by June of 1944 (but not before) had opened up another another front in the west.
Yes, it was the Soviets who actually broke the back of the Nazis, and the Soviets who paid the biggest price and made the most sacrifices to achieve this victory. They paid the heaviest toll, but nonetheless managed to beat the Nazis back, mostly out of necessity. Some have speculated that had the Germans treated the Russians well, that they might have had a real chance. The Soviet regime was indeed brutal, and the people were ready for a change. But the Nazis proved to be even more brutal, and thus, there really was no choice left. They had to fight to get rid of an even worse form of brutality.
The war on the Eastern Front was, again, the most brutal war in all of human history. It was very grim, and there were images and stories from those times that will live on. Ultimately, though, it was the Soviets who turned the tide of the war, and sent the invading forces of Nazi Germany retreating back to the borders of the Reich, and ultimately, continually retreating, until there was little left of Germany itself. The cities were bombed out shells of what they once had been, reduced to rubble. And when the capital fell, it was the Soviet flag that replaced the Nazi one, indicating the de facto end of the European theater of war.
On this day, recognized as V-E Day in Russia, it seemed appropriate to acknowledge that fact, and to give credit where credit is due.
Yes, it was the Soviets who actually broke the back of the Nazis, and the Soviets who paid the biggest price and made the most sacrifices to achieve this victory. They paid the heaviest toll, but nonetheless managed to beat the Nazis back, mostly out of necessity. Some have speculated that had the Germans treated the Russians well, that they might have had a real chance. The Soviet regime was indeed brutal, and the people were ready for a change. But the Nazis proved to be even more brutal, and thus, there really was no choice left. They had to fight to get rid of an even worse form of brutality.
The war on the Eastern Front was, again, the most brutal war in all of human history. It was very grim, and there were images and stories from those times that will live on. Ultimately, though, it was the Soviets who turned the tide of the war, and sent the invading forces of Nazi Germany retreating back to the borders of the Reich, and ultimately, continually retreating, until there was little left of Germany itself. The cities were bombed out shells of what they once had been, reduced to rubble. And when the capital fell, it was the Soviet flag that replaced the Nazi one, indicating the de facto end of the European theater of war.
On this day, recognized as V-E Day in Russia, it seemed appropriate to acknowledge that fact, and to give credit where credit is due.
Below is the link to an article elaborating on just how critical the role of the Soviets was in defeating, and ultimately destroying, the Nazi German threat during World War II:
75 Years Ago, The Soviet Union Saved the World from Hitler’s Nazi Regime by Caleb G., April 6, 2020:
Here is another link to an interesting article:
We Remember World War II Wrong by Adam Tooze, May 7, 2020:
https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/05/07/world-war-2-victory-day-russia-75th-anniversary/
No comments:
Post a Comment